Transcript [00:00] this has been an interesting week in this region the htis continue with their attacks just today [00:04] yesterday and the day before we had missile attacks by the htis launched at Israel and at [00:09] the same time US president Donald Trump does something very unique in this region and he [00:14] speaks to the Iranians directly and he says look what you've been doing through the HTI [00:18] proxies is no longer proxy Warfare everything they do then every bullet that they fire we [00:25] coming after you the Iranians so to really understand that story and really understand [00:30] mechanics of who the htis are and why on Earth a rebel group from Yemen that's 2,000 km away is [00:36] constantly firing rockets at Israel we're talking to the expert on the topic uh her name is Inbal I [00:44] want to get the name of the organization right from she's from the for for regional thinking [00:50] fascinating women we're about to understand how the is work and how it all ties to Israel [01:03] so Inbal thank you for being with us this morning once again thetis fired a rocket [01:09] towards Israel and I'd be interested to hear your take as an expert on htis and Yemen and [01:13] and everything that happens in that part of the world uh how would you explain to my 11-year-old [01:18] daughter why the htis are firing rockets at Israel because I've really run out of explanations to [01:24] to break it down for them when when we were this morning today on our way to the local [01:30] shelter because we heard the alarm at around uh the sirens at around 7 uh then my almost [01:36] three-year-old son said the houis are coming for us so and then he laughed so I'm not sure I have [01:45] I have a good explanation and and you know for your 11-year-old uh girl or my three-year-old [01:50] boy but we have to see um the greater picture and by doing that we actually have to go back [01:59] in to Yemen I often say that if you want to understand the huis before Gaza and the war [02:06] and before their alliance with Iran you have to go back and and bring bring the huis back home into [02:13] Yemen and so they start as a religious revival movement of zidi Islam and also as a social uh [02:23] movement in some ways so part of their legitimacy to operate in the beginning comes from these terms [02:29] they want to save zidi religious practics and zidi Community from our local uh salafi Sunni [02:38] religious establishment that is um in their areas and they uh fear that they might uh steal uh some [02:47] of the Young Generation into Sunni Islam and then there's the whole dimension of periphery of tribal [02:54] groups that they are not being allocated enough um resources to their uh districts and then it it [03:03] opens up to anti-American sentiments anti-israel um anti- Zionist Pro Palestinians and so as they [03:14] grow they fight not only the central government in Yemen in sa for many years from 2004 to 2010 and [03:22] then you have the protest of the Arab Spring and soon enough they take over the capital s 2014 and [03:31] I think that their alliance with Iran as well as uh with the Palestinians uh is ultimately serving [03:40] internal and Regional interests so this is my my take on it the way they they start and they [03:47] operate and then they see any um any Alliance or any connection that might be helpful for [03:55] them they'll use it I'm not saying there's not a genuine Pro Palestinian sentiment or religious [04:01] sentiments in that sort but it is it is definitely I think a tool for them and they are gaining a lot [04:08] of influence a lot of power legitimacy to operate inside Yemen in very um um in very I would say [04:18] violent uh ways and also uh in the region as they show Saudi Arabia and the United Arab [04:25] Emirates their military capabilities and they say you know know if if um if necessary we can [04:34] operate that way against you as well interesting so I want to go back two more steps and I think [04:41] you you hit on a very important topic we sort of automatically move on with our life just with this [04:46] understanding of yes Iran and by extension you know the htis and many other proxies they spend [04:53] for my perspective much of their growth much of the future of their people on a goal that seems [04:59] completely unrelated to to who they are and what they do and the people that they lead [05:04] uh and and you touched on this on what Zid Islam is uh I know very little about this I think most [05:11] people if they know anything about Islam they know that there's Shia and sunnis and that they [05:15] don't necessarily always agree with each other and then some have maybe heard of the you know [05:19] salafi movement in within Islam and I've never you know until we researched this topic until [05:24] thetis became an issue never even heard about zi Islam is there something within their faith [05:30] system that is enough to to make them and I'm looking at the numbers we've talked about this [05:35] many times on you know on this channel they've they've taken their country backwards decades [05:40] when it comes to economic growth and when it comes to financial success when it comes to the quality [05:45] of life of their people they've brought you know Yemen it wasn't doing very well to begin with but [05:50] they've brought it back to a place where it's it seems like almost like an an African country [05:54] after a civil war where there are no jobs there is no Aid the you know the the economy collapsed [06:00] what is it fundamentally in the way they look at the world that that triggers them to behave [06:04] in this way so I think we should say that Yemen is the poorest country in the Middle East even before [06:11] the war um so when it has um almost I think 3/4s of the population which is approximately three [06:22] 32 35 million people are under the age of 25 so they are young wow and they are poor and many of [06:30] the young people are unemployed um so this this is you know to begin with and they rely on supplies [06:38] uh and imported goods almost 90% of it food and other supplies even before the war so this is [06:46] this is the starting point so obviously with the Civil War um it would deteriorate I think that Zid [06:55] Islam and we also have to remember that the huis gave a very specific spefic interpretation to zi [07:02] Islam which is often considered very much closer to uh Sunni Islam rather than the Shia the branch [07:11] of Shia that we know from Iran for that example or from Lebanon with hasbalah so if we are looking or [07:18] trying to say that there's a Shia alliance between Iran and hudis I I'm or between zidi Islam and the [07:25] imet uh the different sect that we see in Iran I'm not sure it's it's that natural but the specific [07:32] interpretation that the huis give to uh to certain uh uh religious aspects of of zidi Islam which [07:41] enables them to use Force as well I think they would take for example the idea of uh fighting uh [07:50] injust or corrupt uh regime so this is something that they would imply inside Yemen against the uh [07:59] president and the and the president uh uh that is now um the head of the uh International recognized [08:07] government in mainly in the in the South but also outside towards Saudi Arabia towards the [08:13] Emirates towards Israel um uh in order to save the Palestinians so I think this is this is one [08:22] aspect but they would take it from Zid Islam and enhance it or or try uh to see it in aad spectrum [08:31] of of Muslims wherever they are that you have to help them and also consider the fact that it gives [08:37] them uh it glorifies them you know Egypt doesn't do much Saudi Arabia doesn't do much much bigger [08:45] countries Sunni countries that are supposed to be Palestinians you know uh immediate brothers and [08:52] saviors are not doing so much and then you see the small hthis from the northern Highlands of Sana [09:01] from the districts of Sada raising the flag for Palestinians and I think it pause I'm I'm losing [09:10] you on the Palestinian side of things and and to me as an Israeli who sits here I often feel and [09:16] I'm sensing that I'm missing something in the way they talk about these topics internally we have a [09:21] lot of problems in the Middle East and there are a lot of problems in the world and I've done a lot [09:25] of like research in the past just out of personal interest the isra Palestinian conflict is is not [09:29] the biggest and it's not even the top 10 biggest conflicts in the world anytime even now during the [09:34] war and yet I I I look at it countries you know it's just this rallying cry come you know let's [09:39] fight for the Palestinians I perceive that and I think many in Israel do as hypocrisy but maybe [09:45] there's something and I'm I'm hearing something in the background of what you're explaining that [09:49] they look at it differently that to them the fact that people are dying in Africa or the Ukraine or [09:55] in Sudan between Muslims and Christians that are fighting isn't an issue and how the Palestinian [10:00] issue is a much higher priority than others for some reason am am is am I correct in saying that [10:07] I think from what from what they say in general they would uh criticize Western influence in [10:16] many other places and also they would pronounce they would say something about it in the case of [10:21] Ukraine as well uh so you would see probably some assistance with think from Russia or from China [10:29] you know they're the way they they see the foreign powers is that you would have the US generally and [10:38] specifically sorry and then the UK and anyone who is a part of the naval Coalition that the [10:44] Americans and the and the British formed um um last year and so of course Israel which is in [10:53] their way some sort of extension uh of the United States but they they critic ize other other actors [11:01] as well but I think the Palestinian issue for them there is a genuine sentiment towards it [11:08] uh as they feel like both both people the zis and the Palestinians are oppressed are ruled by [11:16] um western or pro-western Powers um no one helps them you know they have to help themselves I think [11:24] there's a genuine sentiment for the Palestinians in that way also the religious dimension you help [11:29] Muslims before you help before you help anyone else but I wouldn't be surprised if they form [11:36] alliances with other foreign uh uh actors such as Russia such as China anyone else that would help [11:46] them achieve their their goals so I'm take this one step further when they when the Iranians say [11:54] about the htis they say that look these people aren't a proxy in the way you imagine them to be [12:00] they have an ideology of their own they're not these puppets that we have an on andof switch [12:04] with they do their own thing are the Iranians being honest about that statement and the htis [12:10] actually genuinely care a lot more uh about the the Palestinian Israeli conflict and let's call it [12:15] Islam in this region than we understand them to to care I think this is a great question and I tend [12:21] to agree with the way of thinking that is saying uh let's be careful with the way we are using [12:29] uh the term proxy when it comes uh to the huis and Iranians uh especially if we compare it with [12:38] the relationships they the relationship they had and still have with hisbah in Lebanon in Lebanon [12:44] or with the Iraqi uh militias or even with pro- Syrian um um groups uh with pro-iranian Syrian [12:52] groups this is a different type of of relationship um and H as you said they are a local group they [13:01] are part of the uh ye of yemenese society they started operating on their own mission with their [13:08] own ideology we do see similarities of interests of ideology of maybe strategic goals between them [13:15] and the Iranians the huis definitely uh see themselves as part of the axis of resistance [13:23] as and and as we can see now probably the strongest one that is that is left standing [13:29] but I'm not sure it automatically says that they are an Iranian proxy and I tend to believe I can't [13:38] believe I'm saying that the Iranians when they say that it's not like tahan would uh uh ask theis to [13:47] do something and immediately you know it's not a command they're not it's not if tomorrow they [13:52] say you have to stop doing what you're doing then it's going to be we're going to be done with the [13:56] Hui uh problem so so they operate at their own uh Mission their own interests and if it aligns with [14:05] Iranian interests that's fine we do have to say though that what we see now in terms of military [14:13] capabilities of the huis is very much a result of the alliance with Iran uh they've helped them in [14:21] many ways not only smuggling um uh weapons usually usually in in part by sea and some sometimes [14:32] routes that that go uh into uh the mainland of of Yemen uh intelligence uh training uh people [14:42] that were sent from Lebanon and from Iran to help the the htis for for many years now um so so this [14:50] I think is pretty much agreed upon everyone but the issue of proxy is a little more complicated [14:57] some would say this is completely what tan said that the houis do uh I'm not sure this is the [15:04] case and I think we see it lately but it happened before during the um almost decade of a little bit [15:11] more than a decade of Civil War uh in Yemen so I think we have a bit of a problem because the [15:18] us right now I'm looking back several weeks we I just I'm looking at this article that we have [15:22] here uh president Trump has sort of been grouping together the htis and Iran he so far as to say to [15:30] the Iranians every bullet that thetis fire is it's as if you fired a bullet and then uh you know Al [15:39] he he responds and says that the US will receive and his exact words are severe slaps I I love [15:45] that quote uh if they uh attack or respond with malice towards the us because Trump so Trump is [15:51] threatening that anything thetis do will will be attributed to the Iranians and the Iranians saying [15:58] return you might be surprised in in what you get uh one because you're wrong in in stating this [16:03] these people aren't exactly uh they don't exactly do as you say everything that we tell them to do [16:08] uh and at the same time they're going to see a lot more Regional resistance than they want and I'd [16:13] be interested to hear your take this is something that we we often talk about which is people don't [16:17] understand you know they see the images of thetis and they think oh it's you know it's these guys in [16:21] addressing flip-flops what could they possibly do and maybe give us the picture of how significant [16:27] where they sit geographically Al is and how powerful their interference or their interference [16:32] in the in the in the region is as then when the say we want to disrupt what does that look like [16:38] and what are the implications for global global trade and global stability how powerful are they [16:43] really are okay so I think we have two questions here the um first one is regards the statement of [16:52] President Trump and the answer he got from from tan well I I may suggest a different [16:58] reading or understanding to that I think that Iran is very much responsible to what we see now [17:05] because we already said that the military uh Power and capabilities that we see the the huis have are [17:14] very much a result of the Iranian Alliance or the or Iranian help so in that way I would hold the [17:22] Iranians responsible and I think maybe president Trump was maybe he meant to to to say it that way [17:29] that he see that he holds them responsible in that way that they've made the huis as strong as they [17:36] are having having said that I'm not sure that if you say again that if you ask Iran uh to stop um [17:46] hoodi aggression towards the us or the the naval Coalition or in the Red Sea or towards Israel that [17:53] it's going to stop so I think and this is and I think we see that what what Trump is doing and [18:00] what the Americans are doing in Yemen is proof to the fact that they are not relying only on tahan [18:08] uh to stop huthi aggression but they understand that the huis are operating out of their own [18:14] merits so this is this is the way I see it and and this is my explanation that's how I suggest you [18:22] know to look at it and as for the other question uh Yemen is at the thn uh part of the uh Arabian [18:32] Peninsula and they have a vast Coastline Coastline sorry um to for the Red Sea and also um the babble [18:44] mandab straight now we have to understand that the huis do not control the territory that is um [18:53] the the territory that is um connecting the the Babel mandab straight but uh the north [19:00] part or most parts of the alhuda uh District it doesn't mean that they cannot interfere uh um [19:10] with the with the safe uh traveling uh towards that that route and this is what they do they [19:18] decide um who's going to uh be who who they will permit to go through the The Straits and who will [19:28] not and so we see Egypt suffering very much uh from that uh decision by the huis I don't think [19:37] the International Community reacted fast enough or strong enough in that matter maybe we see uh [19:44] economic forces much more adaptable to the new situation as they change the route uh uh it makes [19:52] everything much more expensive uh ultimately we paid the prices but but you know I wouldn't say [19:59] business as usual at least not for for Egypt or for Jordan uh or for Israel for that matter but [20:07] but it continues you know it it would seem like the economic catastrophe is not as bad as we [20:14] might think because we we see uh that there is a solution and there is an alternative to that route [20:22] I mean you you say that but again when you analyze Iranian and HTI strategy the the numbers vary like [20:30] looking it up as we're as we're talking here let's say in the double digit so minimum 10 and probably [20:35] close to 30% so a lot of the liquid oil uh and a lot of the dry goods that are globally traded [20:42] goes through the Red Sea then the suett canal and you know so people said back back in well [20:48] again the beginning of 2024 you know a lot of the ships sort of just diverted and they started going [20:52] around Africa and it and then some of them tried to go through the land route let's call it across [20:58] the desert then through Jordan Etc it it jacked up the prices of a lot of the goods globally it [21:03] created a shortage uh it's it's so scary that even Whispers of or rumors of disruption of oil [21:11] trade they raise the cost of Commodities of when when oil is traded in in Futures and you look at [21:18] that and you say these people and I think this is sort of an eye-opening moment when you understand [21:23] the economics of it these people who are a relatively small Force they have a disrupting [21:28] power because of where they're located in the world to alter the economy of every country in [21:33] the world almost at once uh and especially when you think about who their neighbors up north [21:38] are you look at the Saudi economy and some of sort of the oil shaks uh in that region [21:44] if they send a couple drones which they've done in the past and they send a couple a couple you [21:48] know pirate vessels and they just enough to scare away the ships they don't even have to [21:52] take over them it's enough to overnight change the economy of this entire region and in that [21:58] sense you look at them they're you know as you said they they really are a superpower and they're [22:03] disrupting uh ability and the fact that they're ideologically driven and not just an onoff proxy [22:09] uh where the the Iranians can say yes today we want it and tomorrow we don't it makes them even [22:14] more uh dangerous because they're not predictable uh because there's a more elastic relationship to [22:19] them and then I would ask the question of so what what do you do with that because they've already [22:25] Aid has already been stopped to Yemen because they started killing some of the aid workers [22:28] in the country they've taken over the ports so it's impossible to bring in Goods without [22:33] going through theis and empowering them and they you know they're they're making very very bold [22:38] threats against America against Israel against the Saudis against everyone who's part of that [22:43] AIS in the region so my question is when someone is so unpredictable and they don't care about the [22:49] the well-being of their people and they're willing to disrupt global trade how do you possibly stop [22:54] them I think it should be an international effort the International Community should ask itself and [23:01] it should have asked itself in in November 2023 do we allow any organization specifically a non-state [23:14] terrorist group that wakes up one morning and decides that it's going to do whatever it wants [23:21] and allows some people to go through a a certain path and others not because this is what they've [23:27] decided to do and are we okay with it because if you look at the naval Coalition that the [23:33] United States and the the British uh formed you have other European um uh Partners in it [23:42] but it's not as as wide as uh unanimous you know as powerful as one would expect and and I think [23:51] this also plays into the hands of the huis uh you don't see a very strong uh opposition to it if you [24:00] compare it to the uh way that the International Community reacted uh years ago to the Somali uh [24:09] pirate Pirates uh along the Somali Coast that was that was a different that was a different case and [24:16] they they very much succeeded the Somali didn't have the somalis didn't have icbms that's true we [24:24] are talking about different military capabilities but it's going to be like that in a you know a [24:29] decade from now it's going to be much harder to defeat any power like that I think there should [24:34] be a uh General decision do we do do we as the International Community allow uh nonstate actors [24:45] or states for that matter to decide what they do with uh strategic and economic uh routes along the [24:54] the Red Sea or any other way or any other place to decide uh um you know if they allow some people to [25:03] go through it or not the damage that the hoodis are causing Egypt you know even if we don't talk [25:08] about International substantial uh Commerce it's huge it's unimaginable and also we have to say the [25:16] damage they do to the economy inside Yemen either the uh internationally recognized government in [25:23] the South and in their own uh areas and as you mentioned uh International Food Aid and other um [25:32] Aid workers are no longer operating at least in Sada maybe in some other parts of Yemen I would [25:38] imagine that now in Sada it's very difficult for them to operate but it doesn't seem uh to have a [25:45] very big effect on the on the hoies so I think the the the reaction to it should have been much much [25:53] faster and much uh and much more severe uh and forceful uh in in that way what in the military [26:04] level military diplomatic yes there should be a very broad Coalition that would step up and say [26:12] we cannot allow something like that and we would react with all the tools that we that we have [26:17] both diplomatic and and Military so so there's this quote trying to think when this was maybe [26:25] four or five months ago uh uh you Central Command had a switch in their their governing General the [26:31] the the leadership and the outgoing General and the incoming General both said we're essentially [26:36] fighting in the Red Sea or the Arabian Sea both of them with our hands tied and what they meant was [26:41] and and there was this whole like document that was it wasn't leaked it was released intentionally [26:45] to the Press which said look if you want to win against terrorists you can't play defense uh the [26:51] only way I think this is sort of in line what you're describing the only way to win against [26:55] someone who is a terrorist whose goal is to destabilize is to attack them and use absolute [27:00] Force against all of their operations and if all you're trying to do is stop their attacks you're [27:06] forever going to be playing a defensive game is that what you have in mind when you say they could [27:10] have been stopped earlier I think that as soon as the uh Naval Coalition realized that what it was [27:17] doing is reacting to Hui aggression rather than trying to uh stop it or fight it then then that [27:27] was you know part of part of the problem but I have to say that this is not something that you [27:33] can solve only by uh military force ultimately the war in Yemen if we bring back again the huis into [27:42] Yemen and the Civil War this is part of the war on the way Yemen would become it's a war it's a war [27:51] on the state of Yemen you know uh is it going what kind of uh government it's going to have [27:58] who is going to rule uh uh which territory because you have many uh powers and many actors in Yemen [28:06] that are fighting to gain uh control over certain areas and resources you have theis you have the [28:16] government that they outed in 2014 you have a separatist movement in the South that is [28:23] uh comprised of many many groups and one of them we see that is uh that is very powerful now with [28:30] the help of the United Arab Emirates you have a separatist movement in the area of you have [28:39] uh tribal autonomous forces you have many actors in Yemen and ultimately you will have to decide [28:48] the way Yemen is going to look the day after if we can try and imagine that so even if you solve the [28:57] the Hui problem in uh you know even if you reduce their military capabilities at the end of the day [29:04] you have to see either do we recognize them as the legitimate actor or power in Yemen and do we [29:11] give them the ability to control any territory and form some kind of government do we want to [29:18] try to talk to another zidi uh sh idea leadership or alternative to the and say listen some of your [29:28] uh requests in the beginning we're just we want to be uh able to answer to them and we are willing to [29:36] give you some part I don't know of Yemen in in sort of like a federative uh plan plan for Yemen [29:43] but then but then you have to decide what you do and I have to say that in that in that term the um [29:50] the negotiations that Saudi Arabia is holding with the houis ever since the middle of 2022 what's it [29:58] what it's doing in a way is is normalizing uh uh the huis because the Saudis wish to buy peace and [30:07] quiet at the border and have the huis uh um stop uh uh shooting missiles or uh or aiming drones at [30:18] them and then they are willing to uh uh make many concessions over that that time to the hes if it [30:25] has to do with Goods that come into Yemen and they will not inspect them if they renew flights uh [30:32] from sa International Airport to Jordan for that matter and this is how I think some of the you had [30:39] the healthy um um operatives go to uh Syria or to Iraq or to other places sometimes under uh student [30:49] Visas so I think what the Saudis do maybe with without intention is that they help normalize the [30:58] and then at the end of the day when you go back and you want to find a sustainable solution for [31:03] Yemen you have to decide who's going to rule which part and who is considered legitimate and [31:09] who is not but may maybe the Saudis are the wise ones in this entire equation because there's this [31:14] mindset I believe in when when people look at the world in a simplified sense where they think that [31:20] problems can be fully resolved and especially in the Middle East but I think anywhere in the [31:24] world without very very dramatic changes that include the displacement of people completely [31:30] uh problems never really go away you still continue to deal with the same ethnic tensions [31:35] and religious tensions and the geopolitics and the economics remain the same for the most part [31:40] they might change the name or the headline or the name of the leader but the problem usually [31:44] persists so the Saudis look at this I'm looking at what they're doing they're playing both sides [31:51] they say look the US hey guys do whatever you can we want a pact with you in this region where you [31:58] commit to protect us against Irani aggression or Iranian aggression against us through the htis [32:05] through uh the irgc through whoever it is we want you to protect us period full stop and we want you [32:10] to guarantee a pact of mutual let's call it protection when it comes to Iranian nuclear [32:16] capabilities at the same time they look at it and they say even if this all goes through on [32:21] the best case scenario for for the Saudis for Israel for the US and the Iranians do agree [32:28] uh to stop with their let's call it practice of of proxy Warfare and they for a season com [32:33] commit to not destabilize this region even then the Saudis still look at the Yemen at the Yemen [32:39] you know like movement and they say look these guys are unpredictable as you say and these guys [32:44] are well equipped these guys are willing to sacrifice almost everything to destroy what [32:48] we care about which is we we care about our control about our economics about our oil and [32:53] if that's the case we might as well negotiate with them because they're not going anywhere uh [32:59] maybe they're correct in the way they look at the world and we're the ones who are sort of you know [33:03] Living in a Dream expecting that a treaty you know with a current president or current prime minister [33:08] will actually change the history in this region I think what the Saudis did is that they started [33:13] out uh war with the Yemen they entered the anti-i Coalition uh in March 2015 and then MBS uh thought [33:28] um somehow that he would be able to finish this in a few months and when the Saudis went to the [33:36] coal into the Coalition they said we are here to eliminate the Iranian extension in the southern [33:43] part of the Arabian Peninsula and to help uh the central government the elected central [33:50] government regain back its power um they have not been able to do any of these two things and [34:00] uh after many long uh years of uh devastating War uh they realized that they have to use diplomatic [34:10] tools but I have to tell you the pictures that the one that we saw uh during 2022 of Hui delegation [34:21] shaking hands with uh senior Saudi uh Statesmen is something that you can hard ly uh believe or [34:29] or imagine I I would say that this is completely a Hy win in that way more than a Saudi realization [34:39] you know uh the hudis brought the Saudis on their knees the way the way I look at it now [34:44] I agree with you that it was much better for the Saudis at at that point and maybe earlier to try [34:51] and negotiate with the with the hooes but we can learn from all the many uh um trials and peace uh [35:02] uh negotiations throughout the last decade that any every time the hudis uh took advantage of [35:10] the peace process and the negotiations to regroup and as they get stronger and the negotiations go [35:18] to uh reaches dead end they will start attacking again so I think this this brings us to a very uh [35:28] um to a to a difficult point of thinking on how we can solve that that issue even if we go to the to [35:35] the negotiation table and I think someone wrote a really interesting article I think it was a year [35:41] or two after the Stockholm Accord which was a very important um uh ceasefire and peace plan [35:48] what is the stock Accord when did that when did that happen it's a it's a pie it was at the end [35:53] of 2018 uh with the help of the international Community it was a conference that was held in [36:00] in in Stockholm and then they started a a road map for the the end to end the war first ceasefire and [36:10] then all kinds of uh promises and concessions from both side regarding aluda the ports regarding uh [36:17] sa International Airport you have some core core issues in the negotiations that go that that come [36:23] up every every time that the two parties sit down and talk with one another or through mediators and [36:30] so what he wrote I think it was a year or two years after the stol Accord um he said I think [36:39] the International Community has what he what he referred to as the Stockholm syndrome you know [36:45] referring to to the agreement and he said maybe we were so eager uh to please the huis and try to [36:56] uh solve this problem in diplomatic ways that we did not notice you know what was happening under [37:02] our nose that we that they didn't really want to solve that problem but they were using uh that [37:09] peaceful time in order to accumulate more power and regroup and then reopen uh War again so this [37:20] is why I say we have to try to find the com the right combination between the military response [37:27] and the Diplomatic effort and I have to say we have to include in the Diplomatic effort which is [37:33] something that the Saudis didn't do because they were hoping to buy their own peace and quiet and [37:38] I can understand that nonetheless you have to uh bring all parties and all actors to the table if [37:46] you want to find hopefully a sustainable solution for the uh for the Hui problem and for sorry and [37:54] for the future of Yemen okay can I challenge what you've been saying I'm I'm running in my [38:00] head through a lot of this description you give you you rais some very fundamental thoughts one [38:06] one of them is is that what tends to happen in the Middle East is once an entity is destabilized we [38:11] end up negotiating with the terrorists that happened with Isis back in the day look at [38:16] Syria as you know as a prime example to that the people that are sort of like the loved government [38:21] of the of Syria right now were fighting alongside Isis just a handful of years ago and and suddenly [38:27] we've know normalize these people you know you look at theis they're a great example of that [38:31] even the Iranian government itself I mean it is a terrorist organization in its nature it is a [38:36] fundamentalist you know Islamic movement that hijacked a country that's really what they are [38:41] in their in their core and you're saying this very statement I agree with like look at look [38:47] you you end up negotiating with these people and at the same time they've never gone back on what [38:51] they said I look at it differently I'd always terminology as far as the terminology goes the [38:57] only only ones who are honest in the Middle East when it comes to politics are the terrorists they [39:01] always tell the truth uh when it comes to their their goals the the democracies we always have [39:06] to to pick words and be you know uh inclusive and kind in in our statements and stuff like that the [39:12] htis have it on their flag their flag says you know Victory to Islam death to America death to [39:17] Israel you know it's it's very clear message and they've never taken it off the flag and [39:22] the same applies by the way to the Iranians same applies to Hamas same applies to they were never [39:28] unclear about their messaging we just chose not to believe them uh which is in a way it's a form [39:33] of I don't know if racism is the word it's a form of of looking down or belittling them and saying [39:39] oh they don't know what they really want If Only They had McDonald's and trade and genes they might [39:44] be happy only to realize time and time again that we don't understand them at all they're very very [39:49] clear about what they want to achieve and they're to to your point I guess they are terrorist [39:54] organization zooming back into the htis that have on their flag and on every statement that they [39:59] make a clear statement of their goals and their intentions and their values we want to destroy [40:03] you we want to destroy everything that stands for that you stand for and your way of life and we're [40:08] willing to stop at nothing to get there and then the west and the Saudis I guess sort of as an ally [40:13] of the West look at that and say well let's try to negotiate with these people there there is no [40:20] middle ground in this negotiation they're saying we want to kill you and say let's negotiate that [40:25] like how how can you possibly negotiate so I think the question really need to be asked is is how [40:30] do you even go about engaging with these kind of organizations like sh is normalization the right [40:35] way to go about it or do you just say look you've you've stated your intent you've made clear who [40:40] you are you've been honest and open and thank you for that now let's respond accordingly so what are [40:46] your thoughts you know you've studied this for for years now um how do you engage with people [40:50] who are so clear about what they intend to do and at the same time hold so much power over everyone [40:55] in the neighborhood I think um in some way we tend to go to diplomatic uh routes um because the [41:06] alternative is much is much worse you know what is the alternative to say okay so we'll fight you [41:13] until the end of war is the alternative exactly no one no one wants to go on you know for an un [41:21] unending uh uh War throughout his life and I don't think any government wants to suggest that as a [41:29] solution to its to its uh to its uh citizens so and and I no democratic government in Bal that's [41:38] the problem no no democratic government right but you know what at the end at the end of the [41:42] day I think in every part of the world if you go uh to the people we basically want similar similar [41:50] things and we have to find a common ground to work with that the problem is as you stated very well [41:57] is how do we deal with terrorist organizations uh when we want to apply diplomatic tools um [42:05] and so the thing is what what may what may we offer them that would convince them to behave [42:11] to behave differently so I think if there are things to offer in the case of the Palestinian [42:18] Israeli conflict we pretty much know uh what what we can offer and then hope that it's going to be [42:24] that it's going to be enough but you would always have that military aspect to it that you have to [42:29] consider the other option the alternative and I agree with you maybe this is how uh Israeli [42:36] governments dealt with Hamas for for many years and uh at least it some some uh for some part for [42:44] some time I thought this was this was a good way to deal with them but as we saw in on October 7 [42:51] 2023 it was not a good idea so and this is why I say sometimes we helped normalize uh those those [43:01] groups but I think one option would be to try as we work with them uh in in military response and [43:10] also uh in in a diplomatic route to try and also look for Al alternative leadership to to those [43:18] groups uh I don't think the huis are a monolitic group from the very beginning of their operations [43:27] some said uh at 2004 look uh violence is not the way to deal with the government let's try other [43:36] ways uh they also had um at um 200 um 2007 I think or before that they had um a a political party and [43:52] one of the main leaders of the Hui family uh was even a minister in one of the governments so I [44:00] think you should try and reason with the more pragmatic uh Parts factions of those factions [44:08] and also to see if there's an alternative I'm sure not all zides are pleased with the way the huis [44:14] operate uh certainly not most most yemenis um but then you have to find the alternative and I think [44:22] part of the the strength and the power that the huis gained inside is not due to the fact that [44:29] they are very strong or not only that but because of the antii Coalition was and still is very much [44:37] UNOH and fragmented and sometimes they fight one another so this also plays into the hands of the [44:45] of the huis um so at the end of the day I think I have in I have to challenge what you're saying [44:53] you you've studied this more more than more than I have I'm going to I'm going to challenge you to [44:57] think for a second think back 50 60 70 years in this region name a time where anyone successfully [45:05] dealt and I don't mean on like a 12-month period I mean successfully dealt with radical movements in [45:11] Dem with Democratic tools as in where a democracy be it western or local dealt with a a a resistance [45:19] movement or a revolutionary movement that was ideologically and religiously driven and did [45:24] so successfully and I'm I'm going to challenge challenge you to find that because I I don't [45:29] think there is uh this isn't an idea I came up with I have a a journalist friend who's spent [45:34] a lot of time in Syria and Lebanon the only thing I've thought and I I would love for you to prove [45:40] me wrong on this the only thing I found is is only strongman dictatorships sort of you know the likes [45:46] of ofus Saddam Hussein the likes of Qaddafi uh the likes of by by the way MBS and mbz in their [45:52] countries in a different way um only by people who are incredibly powerful and Incredibly willing to [46:00] use power and violence against let's call it um the stabilizing factions within their countries [46:07] only then can a tribal Society especially when it comes to Sunni Islam uh can it not sort of fall [46:13] into what we're seeing today in the Middle East which is time and time again you know [46:18] radical movements taking over territories uh Etc um Can can you think of a time where you s someone [46:25] successfully dealt with the likes of the or the likes of Isis or the likes of anyone else and [46:30] didn't leave you know a pile of you know of burnt countries behind and not sure that our area is any [46:38] um is special in that in that sort of way you have radicalism uh throughout the world and in here [46:44] you have uh National aspirations combined with religious uh issues combined with hatred towards [46:52] the west and towards Israel and many other other things and in and interests within those Societies [46:59] or or governments and uh Power uh struggle between between different different groups so I think the [47:06] components are not are not unique in that way but I have to say at the end of the day you cannot [47:14] continue use Force endlessly towards any I mean I agree with you that when you deal with a terrorist [47:22] group uh uh that is attacking you you have to respond back by by force But ultimately this [47:30] is this is a play you know how long can it can it continue you have to do something else if you want [47:36] to uh make any other option or alternative grow in this on that soil uh and so I think that part [47:44] of the Diplomatic effort should be not not only dealing with this group but try to find in for [47:53] that matter in yemeni society or in Palestinian Society and any other Society groups that you [48:00] can help first of all that you can help them uh uh remove uh the terrorist organization from the [48:07] head of the state I don't think Iraqi people could have could could get rid of Saddam by themselves [48:13] they needed help from someone but but what you need to do once you've eliminated him is to help [48:20] local societies uh gain back their uh ability uh to to create their own their own reality it [48:32] may not always work the way that you want to what we see with Iraq now I think is a is a is a good [48:38] example but this is part of the evolving uh play of of societies and you can see that some parts in [48:45] Iraq uh support Iranian uh uh influence but others very much go against it and and this is something [48:54] that you see for example in Iraqi Society but I think also in Yemen you have enough groups that [49:01] do not agree with the hthis that fight the huthis but as we saw they are unable uh uh to get rid of [49:10] of the huis themselves and I think that what the Saudis and Emir Emirates tried to do in the first [49:16] years of the war is was part of a very forceful reaction to the hookies and the Us and other um um [49:27] European and and un and other uh organizations from the International Community uh put a stop [49:35] to some of the Saudi uh Coalition operations because they said listen you have a catastrophic [49:42] humanitarian crisis uh uh in in a minute if you don't stop now and so they were fearing [49:49] the humanitarian crisis and they were just about it so I think also another part that we have to to [49:55] put into the equation is to try and find better ways uh to help uh local societies while we are [50:05] uh operating uh in military ways towards those terrorist organizations and I don't think we [50:11] found that way because at the end of the day the hes as you said before they receive throughout the [50:17] Ala uh ports uh many of the of the humanitarian uh Aid and many of the supplies and they do with [50:25] it whatever whatever they want that's a very good answer there is no there are no easy answers and [50:30] there are no quick fixes so final thought and final question for today zooming back to Iran [50:37] um if tomorrow the Iranians reached an agreement with Israel Saudi the US and others around the [50:44] world and in that agreement they committed to and actually let's say for the most part [50:49] hypothetically they stopped supplying the htis with Munitions and with training Manpower finances [50:57] uh would theti movement as a regional disrupting movement would it sort of fizzle out and disappear [51:03] or would they not be substantially weakened by that I think if uh pressure would be applied [51:11] both from the Iranians and Saudi Arabia and other forces uh with military action and I'm not sure [51:19] it's going to be all peaceful uh then there might be a change but I have to say if that kind of coal [51:26] is formed I think Israel is going to find itself in a very uh fragile position uh and I think this [51:37] is what we saw during the attacks of huies on oil facilities in Saudi Arabia in 2019 I think [51:46] the Saudis realized that the US reaction to it was not what they expected it to be and in part [51:55] it contribut Ed to the Saudis uh trying to reach um an agreement with the Iranians with the help of [52:05] China so we have to be very very careful although Israel would be very happy to get rid of the Hui [52:12] problem the question is what is the price that we are uh uh paying for that and if we are going [52:19] to be able to live with a Saudi Iranian Alliance for that for that matter we live in a complicated [52:25] neighborhood and and I think in the end I always like ending with this thought is I think we always [52:31] have to end with a thought about the life of the people uh and that's always my hope there are no [52:36] quick fixes there are no you know re Regional you know antibiotics that fix fix a problem overnight [52:42] it never happens that way it's always a long process but I think everyone who watches this [52:47] and one I I appreciate the the insight and the time that you've given to this let's call this [52:52] issue these people but it all it always boils down to the humans at the end of it uh for the Yemen [52:58] people what does the future look like and what can be done to Aid them in a way where their life [53:03] doesn't look like it does today in 20 years uh where their cities aren't you know aren't lacking [53:09] electricity and basic necessities where you know women can actually go to school and marry outside [53:15] of force marriages and arrange marriages well how do you reach a a conclusion where life is better [53:20] for them in the long term and I think that needs to be the focus for everyone cuz you know Regional [53:25] Powers shift and they come and go and governments come and go and in the end it has to be focused [53:30] on a process that betters the lives of people in this region uh that has to be the focus for people [53:35] who are looking to fix what's going on here not just on the governmental level but on the human [53:39] level anyway in I want to thank you for taking the time it's been really interesting for me uh I love [53:45] discovering that I don't know much about a topic uh it's always encouraging thank you I think what [53:51] you've said is is the most important we always have to remember that the people who are suffering [53:56] most from healthy aggression are the yemeni people it may be hard for us to remember that [54:02] during these days but we have to uh but we have to remember that perfect thank you Inbal thank [54:11] you hello this is mati here in Jerusalem with TBN Israel this is y Pinto from TBN Israel here [54:21] in Jerusalem TBN Israel is keeping viewers informed with Israel focused news culture [54:27] and what God is doing in this land support TBN Israel today online at tbn.org Israel thank you
Join Mati Shoshani as he sits down with Inbal Nissim-Louvton from the Forum for Regional Thinking to unpack the Houthis’ role in the Middle East, their ties to Iran, and their escalating attacks on Israel. This in-depth conversation explores the roots of the Houthi movement, their strategic disruption of global trade, and the broader geopolitical implications of their actions. With the U.S. and Iran facing off and regional alliances shifting, this discussion offers a crucial perspective on one of the most volatile conflicts in the region.
Please join us in praying for the peace of Israel and Jerusalem.
TBN Israel is creating cutting-edge content that tells the continuing, multi-faceted narrative of Israel. And it all happens through partners like you. Your financial support enables TBN Israel to produce engaging, one-of-a-kind programming that educates viewers around the world about this land and people so loved by God. Donate today: https://www.tbn.org/israel
This video was brought to you by TBN Networks®.
Get weekly summaries of the top news from Israel and the Middle East delivered to your inbox: https://tbnisrael.com/newsletter-signup
WATCH full episodes of Insights: Israel & The Middle East for free on TBN+: https://www.tbnplus.com/c/s/8Bg6gKhf
SUBSCRIBE:
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC73H5p3GP8b5N1f3hozIXyQ?sub_confirmation=1
FOLLOW US:
TBN Israel Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/tbnisrael/
TBN Israel Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/tbnisrael/
#israel #houthis #iran #israelwar #israelnews #tbnisrael